Skip to main content

Stoner, (yawn) continued

I read some negative reviews early on and thought:  What are they talking about?   Sadly, now I know.  The book now feels like a summary of a book.  I won't go back and reread the first half because I enjoyed it so much and don't want to spoil it, but for me that spark of magic went out with the "wonderful vacation" (yawn) of Katerine and Stoner before they must part.

Plot spoilers coming.

Since then:  The parting seemed highly unlikely.  Way too literary in the worst sense.  We were told they were passionately in love, yet the part like platonic pen pals--each rationally realizing parting is wise.  Too rational.

Stoner's troubles with Lomax over the crippled student continue and continue.  He has to teach freshman composition classes instead of graduate seminars (yawn).  Not exactly a crisis.

His wife becomes Nixonesque--referring to others and herself in the third person.

His daughter Grace -- out of nowhere -- gains 50 pounds.  Then, a couple of years later, she loses 50 pounds.  She's phlegmatic in the extreme.  Nothing particularly interests her.  She gets pregnant by a boy whom she doesn't care for, marries him because Mom insists.  He dies in WWII.  Grace, living in St. Louis, develops a drinking problem, but even that is boring.

So sad, because I was liking it so much

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin . . . finished

 Follows Sadie and Sam (Mazer) from childhood to mid-thirties when both are feeling old and a bit out of it in the gaming world.  Characters are well-rounded, develop throughout the novel in interesting way.  Plot is involved but sensible.  Not a single, "Oh, come on!" moment.  The book could have been faster paced. Odd, since the main topic is video games which are not for their speed of engagement and Gabrielle Zevin clearly knows her video games. Recommended by Michael Connelly in an interview.  He also has Bosch pick up the book in his novel, Resurrection Walk, as Bosch tails a possible witness to a crime as she moves through a bookstore. Sadie and Sam do not get together at the end, which is good.   Marx killed by homophobic nutcase who really wants to kill Sam, but Sam isn't there. Marx is father of Sadie's child. 

The Franchise Affair, Josephine Tey--opening pages

Blair, a lawyer in Milford, gets a strange call.  His practice is wills and similar--nothing criminal.  A woman tells him that Scotland Yard is accusing her of abduction and implores him to come out to help her, even if later on he passes the case to someone else.  The woman says she has called him because he is "her type," meaning respectable and conservative.  He agrees.