Skip to main content

North and South continued

Gaskell's take on unions seems to come to this.  The unions, if they force men to join, are guilty of the same sort of tyranny as owners.  Our strong union man (Higgins) is made to seem somewhat responsible for the suicide of a fellow worker who didn't want to join the union but was forced to.

This "freedom first" sounds good, but Gaskell downplays the power of $$$. If management has the money and there is no union or a weak union, freedom won't feed the stomach.

Plot now revolves more around Frederick than anything else.  Lennox returns as a lawyer who might represent him in his attempt to get his name cleared.  Thornton continues to (sort of) suspect that pure Margaret has a hidden lover. Margaret, who lied to the police about being at the train station when Frederick pushed his potential Judas down and sort of caused his death, is humiliated by her lie. She has lost Thornton's good will and she has betrayed her own principles.

It's all entertaining but it also seems contrived.  Thornton and Margaret are headed to the altar once all the misunderstandings are cleared up.  Not sure that Frederick will ever by cleared--does the English Navy ever forgive mutiny?  Also suspect that Lennox will do some sort of dirty dealing with Frederick that disappoints Margaret, thereby clearing the stage for Thornton.

Like the first half far more than the second.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Puppy, Story by George Saunders

PUPPY  Dysfunctional family has puppy that they need to get rid of.  Mom places ad; family is coming over. Description of family.   Mom:  husband changed from long-haired attractive to stooped old man. Husband: talks constantly of living on a farm and doing what needs to be done, though he never lived on a farm.   Conversations together:   Sell and move to Arizona, get hooked on phonics for kids, buying a car wash. . . wonderful randomness. Straight-laced suburbanite comes to look at puppy.  Seems like she will buy it, even though she is repelled by house.  (Dog turds on carpet, filthy.) She is proud of how accepting she is until she looks out window and sees white trash's son tied by harness to a tree.  Reader knows he is a menace to himself, darting across I-90, for example.  Suburban mother beats hasty retreat, leaving dog to be (probably) drowned by dad who does what has to be done.   Suburbanite remembers her own pathetic ch...

Full Dark House by Christopher Fowler

Bryant & May--Peculiar Crimes Unit Mystery, Book 1 Lots that I liked.  Crime novel that is also historical fiction.  Fowler gives insight into London during the blitz.  Danger from street cars, some looting during blackout, stiff upper lip British still going to theaters, etc.  Fowler also takes reader backstage into the workings of a theater.  I learned a lot about the physical complexity of a major theater--production is a tremendous production.  I liked both the main characters.  Bryant, the eccentric loner who thinks out of the box. May, the more traditional "bright" guy, who is able to appreciate Bryant and help by keeping him in the real world, a little. Plot revolves around murders committed while cast rehearses and then performs Offenbach's scandalous version of Orpheus and Eurydice.  The murders are on the gruesome-detail side given the general British coolness of the rest of the text.  Spoiler coming.  The denouement wa...

Sorcerer, Movie 2.5 stars

Roy Scheider, based on Wages of Fear. Scheider is involved in a robbery in USA.  He robs a church connected to the mob--the mob puts out a contract to kill him.  He flees to Nicaragua.  Poor, miserable . . . and a contract killer shows up.  He takes his chance--driving a cargo of plastic explosives over a mountain to put out an oil well fire. His would-be killer, though a series of events, becomes his co-driver.  The other truck has a Frenchman involved in a financial scheme who has had to flee France. He, too, needs money to get out of the miserable little town. Driving the trucks is the focus of last half of movie.  Explosion at every turn is possible.  Frenchman and his co-driver blow up when wheel comes off.  Scheider's co-driver killed by bandits (Scheider and he have become respectful of one another.) Scheider carries the explosives in. He will get 40,000 pesos.  He's about to fly out of the little town, with some hope, when a car...