Skip to main content

North and South, Elizabeth Gaskell

I've liked other Gaskell novels, and this one is promising.  Mostly interesting characters.
Father (Richard) is a vicar who is forced by his conscience to give up his living and his wonderful little vicarage in the south of England.  He is a dissenter--basically believes that the Church of England is too involved in the world (at least that's what I think it means). I believe this is part of the "disestablishment" movement which wanted the church and stage separated.  He also seems -- in some things -- inert. He doesn't tell his wife any of his doubts, and she learns that they are leaving their home only two weeks before the move--and then from the daughter, Margaret.  Her husband can't bear to tell her, so he doesn't.

Margaret.  Nineteen. Has spent 10 years in London with an aunt learning to be a lady so is not close to her mother, though the book pretends that she is close somehow with the father. Hard to see how.  She is haughty, aristocratic, but with a good heart.  She'd be pride and prejudice in the Austen novel, the prejudice being against tradespeople.

Mother:  Maria.  Not too interesting.

The family moves to the north, to Milton, a mill/factory town.  Smoky, dirty, filled with manufacturers and tradesman.  Margaret is repelled, has no interest in seeing the mills, looks down on tradesmen, etc.  Strong contrast between North and South of England, with the south being "Virginia" and the north more "Pittsburgh."

Dad has taken a job as a tutor, is more open-minded, and is particularly fond of Thornton, a young man with drive who wants to fill in his practical education with classical learning so takes classes from Dad.  Thornton and Margaret don't connect . . . but they will. Margaret is also being pursued by Lennox, sort of.  He's an aristocrat, more suited in some ways, but he lacks the basic honesty and drive of Thornton.  He's going to lose.

Thornton's mother looks down on  Margaret and all the fancy aristocrats of south England.  Good, minor character.

Margaret befriends Bessie and her family. Bessie is dying of lung ailment from cotton factory.  This subplot feels very Dickensian--Margaret will get her heart here, I think.

Margaret's brother Frederic is a lost soul--a sailor involved in a mutiny.  His disaster partly explains father's depression.

So, bold strokes all the way around, but really well-written and engaging.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Puppy, Story by George Saunders

PUPPY  Dysfunctional family has puppy that they need to get rid of.  Mom places ad; family is coming over. Description of family.   Mom:  husband changed from long-haired attractive to stooped old man. Husband: talks constantly of living on a farm and doing what needs to be done, though he never lived on a farm.   Conversations together:   Sell and move to Arizona, get hooked on phonics for kids, buying a car wash. . . wonderful randomness. Straight-laced suburbanite comes to look at puppy.  Seems like she will buy it, even though she is repelled by house.  (Dog turds on carpet, filthy.) She is proud of how accepting she is until she looks out window and sees white trash's son tied by harness to a tree.  Reader knows he is a menace to himself, darting across I-90, for example.  Suburban mother beats hasty retreat, leaving dog to be (probably) drowned by dad who does what has to be done.   Suburbanite remembers her own pathetic ch...

Full Dark House by Christopher Fowler

Bryant & May--Peculiar Crimes Unit Mystery, Book 1 Lots that I liked.  Crime novel that is also historical fiction.  Fowler gives insight into London during the blitz.  Danger from street cars, some looting during blackout, stiff upper lip British still going to theaters, etc.  Fowler also takes reader backstage into the workings of a theater.  I learned a lot about the physical complexity of a major theater--production is a tremendous production.  I liked both the main characters.  Bryant, the eccentric loner who thinks out of the box. May, the more traditional "bright" guy, who is able to appreciate Bryant and help by keeping him in the real world, a little. Plot revolves around murders committed while cast rehearses and then performs Offenbach's scandalous version of Orpheus and Eurydice.  The murders are on the gruesome-detail side given the general British coolness of the rest of the text.  Spoiler coming.  The denouement wa...

White Lotus #2

 Tanya and new characters in Sicily. Harper & Ethan, rough patch in marriage despite new wealth Daphne and Cameron, slick couple, Cameron a cad, Daphne at peace with it. Separated one night, C & E have hookers over.  C sleeps with them; E doesn't.  Harper finds condom pack . . . accuses E.  He denies. In revenge, she (probably) has sex with C.  In revenge, E probably has sex with Daphne. Tanya set up for murder by Greg, husband.  Gay guys in Sicily will show her a good time (sex with gigolo) and then kill her.  She ends up shooting all of them and then drowning when she tries to get off the boat. Portia, her assistant, is with her lover, a bad boy who probably was supposed to kill her but instead takes her to the airport and tells her to get away Family visiting ancestral home.  Dad is sex addict on outs with wife.  Son is Stanford grad, a bit of a dufus. Grandad cynical old guy with old guy values.  Two hookers set up the young ...