Skip to main content

Strangler Vine finished

The resolution of the mystery is not strong.  In essence, Blake discovers that the bureaucrat he thought responsible was, instead, simply mistaken in his persecution of the thugges, not evil.  However, another bureaucrat was downright evil.  Really, as a reader, which bureaucrat is to blame isn't compelling.  Blake and Avery also agree to keep their discoveries and the facts around the murder of Mountstuart semi-hushed up . . . again, not dramatic.

However . . . the creation of the feel of India was great.  Both Avery and Blake were well-rounded.  The afterward helps in understanding the historical context and the controversy over the "thugs."  Did they even exist.  An example of the subtlety:  Avery ends the book with the plan to marry his sweetheart.  Blake congratulates him, then says something to the effect of:  "But you know, my young friend, your eyes have been opened to the corruption at the core of the English domination of India.  Can you really be a good English husband going to English parties in India?  Will you be able to listen to the nonsense?"  It's a good questions . . . the happy marriage ending is undercut.  I'll read another by M.J. Carter.

Oh, exciting gunplay, fighting, escapes.  As much an adventure story as a mystery.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Tess of the D'Urbervilles, continued 2/3rds

"To all humankind, Tess was only a passing thought. Even to friends, she was only a frequently passing thought." Angel Clare is a good character. He's "enlightened," in so many ways, but when Tess's confesses her "crime," he reverts to ancestral form . . . Tess's "confession" comes earlier than I expected, right after Angel reveals that he has had a bad moment with a woman. Tess points out the similarity in their transgressions, though his is the only true transgression, expecting forgiveness. She doesn't get it. She returns to her mother . . . realizes she can't stay with her. Thoughts to suicide. Unhappiness that divorce is not possible. Departs. Tragic in that the two, if Angel could just see clearly, would indeed be a great couple, each adding to the other.  Nature as a definite force involved in the tragedy.  It's not neutral--when things go bad, the very skies mock Tess. Tess as unaware of the power of her bea...
Post a Comment
Read more

Napoleon 14 Amiens

"Ambassadors are essentially spies with titles."  Napoleon President of Italy . . . Peace treaty with England (Amiens) in March 1802, with Turkey in June 1802 . . . flawed peace treaty with England because there was no opening up of France for trade with England, infuriating the English who thought peace would mean trade. . . tourism, though--Brits come to Paris and admire Napoleon . . . British liberals enamored . . . Napoleon "consul for life" . . . lots of unsettled territories, Switzerland being the largest . . . Industrialization much greater in England than France . . . France in 1802 is about the same as England in 1780 as a manufacturing center . . . Napoleon is basically Anglophobic, complaining of any art work that celebrates English victories being shown in Louvre . . . peace unraveling . . . by 1803 . . .  War May 18, 1803! . . . Louisiana Territory sold, advantageous to both parties.  France gets money; USA gets land.  France avoids possible war with ...
Post a Comment
Read more