Skip to main content

Great Reckoning finished

Plot turns on discovery that the murdered professor (LaDuc) was forcing his cadets to play Russian Roulette a la Deer Hunter.  That's tough to swallow, as none of the cadets die even though the "game" had been played over a three or four year period--seemingly at least a dozen times.  What was La Duc going to do with a dead cadet's body in his study?  The map had no connection to the murder, just a add-in for local color and history.  Disappointing.  The actual murderer (his childhood friend) was fine.  Garmand had given this guy a second chance.  He was repaying Garmand by murdering LaDuc before La Duc could ruin the police college.

Amelia Choquet, the pierced girl whom we are encouraged to believe is Garmand's illegitimate daughter is actually the daughter of the boy who killed Armand's parents in a car crash. She's a total cliche.  The tough girl who is really kind at heart and also smarter than all those people with conventional backgrounds.

Plot is too long and too loose for my taste.  Character of Armand too cloying--he's perfect. Writing style is excellent.  I think this will by my only Louise Penny novel.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Oppenheimer . . . film

 Solid opening 30 minutes (we're treating this like a mini-series).  O's involvement with left-wing causes . . . rift with Einstein (O thinks of him as over-the-hill and Einstein knows it.)  First splitting of atom.  Lawrence Lab in Berkeley--Lawrence practical applied physics . . . not O's strength.  Main actor is from Peaky Blinders.

The Master Chapter 2

February 1895 (Alice died in 1892) Money problems, jealousy of Wilde; time spent with Lord Wolseley1; off to Ireland to lick his wounds; Irish unrest--Irish landlords boycott all social events; much time spent with manservant Hammond (homosexual attraction again); fancy dress ball, appalling to James, who is only happy in company of Hammond, though Hammond remains a servant and no more; little girl alone on the grounds--inspiration for Turn of the Screw?; conflict with Webster who alludes to Wilde's successful play and HJ's failure; Wolseley was an  Anglo-Irish  officer in the  British Army . He became one of the most influential and admired British generals after a series of successes in Canada, West Africa, and Egypt, followed by a central role in modernizing the British Army in promoting efficiency. He served in Burma, the  Crimean War , the  Indian Mutiny , China, Canada and widely throughout Africa—including his  Ashanti  campaign (1873–1874) and the  Nile Exp